N※N

Show Food and Wine Publications

Rochester Restaurants Shine: Char & Rose Tavern Earn Wine Spectator Award

Rochester's Culinary Gems Shine: Char Steak & Lounge and Rose Tavern Earn Wine Spectator's 2025 Award of Excellence

In a testament to Rochester's burgeoning fine dining scene, two local establishments have been honored with the prestigious Wine Spectator 2025 Award of Excellence. Char Steak & Lounge, perched atop the Strathallan Hotel, and Rose Tavern at The Lake House on Canandaigua, have both been recognized for their exceptional wine programs, joining an elite group of restaurants worldwide that excel in curating impressive selections of vintages. This accolade, bestowed by Wine Spectator magazine, highlights venues that demonstrate a deep commitment to wine culture, offering lists that are well-chosen, appropriately priced, and thematically aligned with their menus. For these Rochester-area spots, the award not only celebrates their dedication but also underscores the region's growing reputation as a destination for oenophiles and food enthusiasts alike.

The Wine Spectator Restaurant Awards program, now in its 44th year, evaluates thousands of applicants annually across three tiers: the Award of Excellence, the Best of Award of Excellence, and the Grand Award. The entry-level Award of Excellence, which both Char and Rose Tavern have secured, requires a wine list of at least 90 selections, showcasing a broad spectrum of producers and regions while complementing the restaurant's cuisine. What sets these winners apart is not just the quantity but the quality and thoughtfulness behind their offerings. Evaluators look for lists that are visually appealing, accurately presented, and paired with knowledgeable service—elements that both restaurants have mastered through years of refinement.

Char Steak & Lounge, a sophisticated rooftop venue known for its panoramic views of downtown Rochester, has long been a go-to for steakhouse classics elevated with modern flair. Under the guidance of its culinary team, the restaurant has built a wine program that emphasizes bold reds to match its prime cuts of beef, alongside lighter options for seafood and vegetarian dishes. The list features an array of international selections, from robust California Cabernets to elegant French Bordeaux, with a nod to New York State's own Finger Lakes wineries. This local integration is particularly noteworthy, as Char sources bottles from nearby producers like Heron Hill and Dr. Konstantin Frank, blending global prestige with regional pride.

Speaking to the significance of the award, the general manager at Char Steak & Lounge described the honor as a validation of their ongoing efforts to create memorable dining experiences. "We've always believed that a great meal is incomplete without the perfect wine pairing," they explained. "Our team spends countless hours tasting, researching, and updating our list to ensure it evolves with trends and guest preferences. Winning this award from Wine Spectator feels like a pat on the back for everyone involved—from our sommeliers to our servers who guide guests through the selections." Indeed, the restaurant's staff undergoes regular training to stay abreast of wine trends, ensuring that even novice diners feel empowered to explore beyond their comfort zones.

The wine list at Char is meticulously organized by varietal and region, making it accessible yet sophisticated. Standouts include rare vintages like a 2010 Château Margaux, priced competitively to encourage exploration, and more approachable options such as a Finger Lakes Riesling that pairs beautifully with the lounge's charcuterie boards. The venue's ambiance—complete with sleek leather seating, ambient lighting, and those stunning cityscape views—further enhances the wine-drinking experience, turning a simple glass into a sensory journey. Patrons often rave about the lounge's happy hour specials, where discounted wines allow for sampling without breaking the bank, democratizing access to high-quality pours.

Meanwhile, Rose Tavern at The Lake House on Canandaigua offers a contrasting yet equally compelling wine narrative. Nestled in the scenic Finger Lakes region, this tavern draws inspiration from its lakeside setting, focusing on fresh, seasonal ingredients that reflect the area's agricultural bounty. Its wine program is a love letter to the local terroir, heavily featuring Finger Lakes varietals like cool-climate Chardonnays and Pinot Noirs, while also venturing into Old World classics from Italy and Spain. The tavern's approach is rustic yet refined, with a list that emphasizes sustainable and organic producers, aligning with the eco-conscious ethos of The Lake House resort.

The executive chef at Rose Tavern highlighted how the award reinforces their mission to showcase the Finger Lakes as a world-class wine destination. "We're surrounded by some of the best vineyards in the country," they noted. "Our list is designed to tell a story—of the land, the winemakers, and the flavors that thrive here. Receiving the Wine Spectator Award of Excellence motivates us to keep pushing boundaries, perhaps by introducing more biodynamic options or hosting themed tasting events." Indeed, Rose Tavern frequently organizes wine dinners, where guests can enjoy multi-course meals paired with selections from featured wineries, fostering a deeper appreciation for the craft.

The tavern's wine selection spans over 100 bottles, with by-the-glass options that rotate seasonally to highlight peak expressions. For instance, a crisp Sauvignon Blanc from New Zealand might accompany a summer salad of heirloom tomatoes and local goat cheese, while a hearty Syrah from Washington State warms up winter evenings alongside braised short ribs. The staff's expertise shines through in their recommendations, often drawing on personal anecdotes or food pairing insights to enhance the guest experience. The setting itself—a cozy, wood-paneled space with views of Canandaigua Lake—creates an intimate atmosphere conducive to lingering over a bottle, making it a favorite for romantic getaways or celebratory gatherings.

Both restaurants' achievements come at a time when Rochester's food scene is experiencing a renaissance. With the Finger Lakes wine region gaining international acclaim—boasting over 100 wineries and accolades from bodies like the International Wine Challenge—these awards spotlight how local establishments are leveraging this momentum. Char Steak & Lounge and Rose Tavern are not isolated successes; they represent a broader trend of Rochester venues investing in wine education and curation. Other area spots have previously earned similar honors, but this year's recognitions for Char and Rose underscore a commitment to excellence that resonates globally.

For diners, these awards translate to tangible benefits: assurance of a thoughtfully assembled wine list, expert guidance, and pairings that elevate every meal. Whether it's savoring a steak at Char with a velvety Merlot or enjoying lakeside tapas at Rose with a vibrant Rosé, the experience is enriched by the knowledge that these venues have been vetted by one of the wine world's most respected authorities.

Looking ahead, both restaurants plan to build on this success. Char Steak & Lounge is considering expanding its cellar to include more rare allocations, while Rose Tavern aims to collaborate with local winemakers for exclusive bottlings. Such initiatives not only sustain their award-worthy status but also contribute to the cultural fabric of Rochester, drawing visitors from afar and boosting the local economy.

In an era where dining out is about more than just food—it's about storytelling, connection, and discovery—the Wine Spectator 2025 Award of Excellence serves as a beacon for Char Steak & Lounge and Rose Tavern. These honors affirm that in the heart of upstate New York, exceptional wine experiences are not just possible but thriving, inviting all to raise a glass to Rochester's flavorful future.

(Word count: 1,048)

Read the Full Democrat and Chronicle Article at:
[ https://www.democratandchronicle.com/story/news/2025/08/01/char-steak-lounge-and-rose-tavern-win-wine-spectator-2025-award-of-excellence-new-york/85461773007/ ]